Guest Post: Ice Cream, as a Pie!


A guest post by my daughter Laura Younger:

It’s only June and the weather is h-o-t!  I wouldn’t call myself a huge ice cream person, but as soon as summer hits, I love it!  Especially because ice cream reminds me of going to the beach.  Growing up, our family beach trips involved ice cream sandwiches, after-dinner trips to Scoops Ice Cream parlor, and memories of my dad drinking the last of the melting cream out of the carton.

Over our Memorial Day beach trip, I was in charge of making the dessert for fish taco night. While I knew the fam would be happy enough with a gallon (or two), I wanted to put a bit more effort into the final product – And with three bloggers in the family, presentation is everything.

Enter ice cream pie.  Easy, cheap, and loved by all.  Especially, my pregnant sister.

Ice Cream Pie:

 Crush 24 Oreos (or Joe’s Joes) in a plastic bag with something hard or use a food processor – they don’t have to be very fine because the bigger chunks of cookie taste great!

Mix crushed cookies with 1/4 cup melted butter until well combined

Press mixture into a pie pan using the back of a spoon and let harden in freezer (30 minutes minimum) or fridge (1 hour)

Spread one carton of ice cream into piecrust. Note: it’s best to let the ice cream sit out for a while or make the pie when you get home from the grocery store and the ice cream has softened enough to spread

Put pie back in freezer for at least an hour

Serve with whipped cream, cherries, butterscotch, and chocolate syrup!

Photo: Laura, who blogs over at Taking Back My Twenties, is 26 and loves dessert almost as much as I do.

13 responses »

  1. Love this recipe–especially the oreo crust–and will make it this weekend. Thank you. HOT here in Denver. More than 100 degrees on most days. A little early for that. We usually don’t get that kind of heat until mid-August. But, well…it make everyone look like she/he is having a hot flash, no?

  2. Great recipe! Thanks for sharing, Laura. Two good things – pie and ice cream. Why have one without the other?? 😉 My favorite ice creams are Black Cherry and Salted Caramel. I think either one would work wonderfully in this recipe.

    I owned a chocolate/fudge shop years ago in Wisconsin and also had hard-serve ice cream (Cedar Crest made in Wisconsin.) This was the real stuff, full of fat, and oh so delicious. Luckily I don’t have a sweet tooth, since I had access to all this ice cream any time I wanted it. Yikes! But now I can imagine making a pie using several flavors, in layers. That would be a lot of fun. Not worth opening an ice cream shop for, though. I hurt my shoulder trying to scoop that hard stuff. Yup. When I went to my doctor, I told her it was an “ice cream related injury.” She said that was a first on her books. 😉

    Thanks again, Laura, for sharing the recipe. And thank you, Barbara, for inviting your lovely daughter to join the ride.

Comment on this post

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s